Avid dnxhd vs apple pro res codec for windows

For professional editing software users, this powerful video converter app can transcode blackmagic footage for final cut pro x76, imovie, premiere pro cs6cc, sony vegas pro 16, avid media composer, etc. This sample is from the official apple prores codec controlled by adobe media encoder on mac osx. Oct 03, 2019 today avid announced that media composer will deliver native support for apples prores raw camera codec and support for prores playback and encoding on windows. Dnxhd 220 30p 175 24p is almost identical to the quality of prores. So it depends on what nle you use, but the best thing is to try both versions of dnxhd and prores to see what works best for you.

Creating a custom quicktime prores or dnxhd master output. Avid hd intermediate codec dnxhd is useful if you want convert hdvavchd to a format codec that is supported in more editorsa mov with avid dnxhd. Does anyone know or have an opinion on why prores is so dominant stateside. Apple prores is one of the most popular video formats in professional video production and postproduction. My knowledge on the topic of using avid dnxhd has all come from john rofrano, who is one of the best vegas pro experts you will find anywhere. Get avid dnxhr and dnxhd and avid resolution independence to meet the challenges working with high res media presents, work at the speed of your creativity, and meet the most demanding deadlines presented by todays demand for 4k and 8k content. I dont edit on a pc or premiere pro, but i would think dnxhd should come up in your export settings. Mar 03, 2017 best lossless codec for exporting video without quality loss on mac and pc for film in premiere pro. I thought, since prores is an apple codec, that i could just import the prores on an avid mac machine, but no luck. Avid media composer and symphony ship with a wide range of old and modern codecs. I am editing an hd project and i just realized that i dont have apple prores codec. Apple prores proxy mxf vs dnxhd 36 forum for avid media composer users discuss techniques, support and other issues in the cows avid user support forum. In fact, prores and dnxhd sometimes called intermediate or production codecs sit in a kind of sweet. How to export dnxhd hr from davinci resolve and not wash.

Apr 19, 2019 in addition, the program can also help you transcode h. Transcode and import apple prores codec into avid media composer. If you ever wondered what the number in each dnxhd preset means, its the bitrate in megabits per second. These offer varying levels of compression that result in different file sizes. Avid delivers video editing workflows with prores raw and dnx. Apple prores and avid dnxhd provide the benefit of a complete. Inside an mxf container you can have prores, dnxhr, or any number of other codecs. The dnxhd codec will more than likely come in a choice of. Whats more, apple will provide 64bit decoders for dnxhr and dnxhd codecs. Apple releases prores raw beta for windows macrumors. Mar 29, 2019 ive got a 2 and a half hour 1080p prores file that i need to import into avid. The board includes three operating points of apple prores and two operating points of avid dnxhd from the release date planned for end of december.

Apple prores is a high quality, lossy video compression format developed by apple inc. That means that theyre actually running apples code, so they produce real, dependable, prores files exactly as they would appear if encoded by final cut pro. Adding support for prores for windows, native prores raw and dnx codecs is yet. Avid announced improved endtoend video editing workflows with prores integration for windows and native support for prores raw in. Heres another chance to read this article about why its a good idea to use prores, avid dnxhd, and any of the other production quality compression c redshark news why you should use avid dnxhd and apple prores. What i mean by that is, other capture codecs are transcoded to these for editing. So when using the codec in avid you can transcode media and have it keep its source size and framerate no matter what kind of timeline you are in.

Redshark news why you should use avid dnxhd and apple prores. Answering questions on problems using another gui to export apple pro res on windows. Apple prores and avid dnxhd provide the benefit of a complete video file contain with audio embedded. Where im based ireland mxf variants are pretty much the standard for masters delivery. Mar 16, 2017 apple prores proxy mxf vs dnxhd 36 forum for avid media composer users discuss techniques, support and other issues in the cows avid user support forum.

Most windows only users probably use avid dnxhd and apple users stick with prores, however it really depends on the individual and their workflow and what devices they work with. A few pieces of software running on windows scratch, nuke, and nucoda have licensed the prores encoder from apple. Avid adds prores raw support to media composer 2019 4k. Mar 05, 2015 the latest version of most pro editing apps premiere, avid, etc. Dpx, or any other combination, youve come to the right place. In addition, unless you owned avid media composer, the only available components were older and had reduced functionality. Avid adds prores raw support to media composer 2019. Then the former would win this test, and the latter would look better. Apr 24, 2016 prores vs dnxhd which is better for editing 4k.

Prores is a codec technology developed by apple for highquality, highperformance editing in final cut pro x. If you want to compare prores vs dnxhd, prores vs cineform, dnxhd vs. In this video i compare the apple prores and dnxhd codecs on my. Prores codecs are all 10bit 422 as is dnxhd 220x but lower bit rate dnxhd codecs are 8bit 422 architectures. Why prores on windows is still not a good option for editors. Best lossless codec for exporting video without quality loss. With this blackmagic video converter, you can encode blackmagic dnxhd mxf, prores 422 mov, quicktime mov, h.

These integrations will allow content creators and post. But in the export menu, send to quicktime movie i dont have the option to use apple prores 422. We take a frank look at the state of prores on windows computers. Prores raw applies prores compression to the raw data from a camera sensor to provide the flexibility of raw video with the performance of prores for editing. Miraizon dnxhd and prores codecs for windows version history. These were encoded by adobe media encoder to the mov container using avid s official quicktime codec. One of the most common types of exports that editors use when they export from adobe premiere pro is a master file. There are subtle differences between each of the codecs that are recorded. Avidqualified video codecs for pro tools 11, 12, 2018 and 2019 pro tools. Youll see substantially less blocking artifacts in detailed areas in comparison to avid dnxhd with some subtle blocking in areas of low detail. I work on both mac and pc and find mxf a great format as moving a project between the two is no.

I dont know the ins and outs of codecs the way engineers do. Apple prores and prores raw authorized products apple support. Apple today released prores raw for windows in a beta capacity via mark gurman, with the software designed to allow prores raw and prores raw. Use the codecs in quicktime pro, avid, vegas movie studio, vegas for example. This limited the useability of the dnxhd codec on the macintosh platform. Best lossless codec for exporting video without quality. Encoding videos in prores 422 hq on windowspc envato forums. Aug 07, 2017 authorized prores on windows options arent practical. How to transcode prores to dnxhd easily and quickly brorsoft. Apple has done its best to keep prores off pcs, so its not universally supported on windows systems. Its my first time when my client asked me to provide apple prores video format, soi have to do it. Avid dv sd codec used when exporting dv material avid mpeg2 50 sd codec for mpeg 30, 40 or 50 material.

The continued availability of avids dnxhd and dnxhr decoders for macos is a benefit to content creators using apple and avid products and will ensure the longevity of content creators dnx material encoded in mxf and quicktime files. It seems avid mc5 doesnt install the codec with the pe codecs package. Raw camera codec alongside support for prores playback and encoding on windows. I know grass valley released their codecs for pc and mac for free, so maybe you could use those as an export codec. May 29, 2007 using the prores 422 hq codec as intended it delivers as promised and a bit better than expected. This is contained by a highquality codec like apple prores.

Avid dnxhd vs prores for vegas editors creative cow s vegas pro user support and discussion forum is a great resource for vegas users wishing to learn more about vegas without all the noise. In order to play dnxhd files created with our codecs on a different system, either our codecs or the avid dnxhd codec must be installed on that system. Dnxhd, however, lacks the hipster cache of prores and mac cultists. What are the differences between prores, dnxhd and cdng. Installing the free pro res quicktime codec for windows.

Blackmagic vdieo converter transcode dnxhd and prores 422 files. Prores raw support comes to avid media composer newsshooter. Avid today announced that media composer will deliver native support for apple s prores raw camera codec and support for prores playback and encoding on windows. While dnxhd codec components have been available for some time, fully threadsafe components have been missing. This may be related to turn around time, storage capacity and post production capability. The problem is that it takes like 20 hours on import. Saw there was a prores for windows codec for windows i have a pc but quicktime doesnt read my. Then i installed it on my mac and adobe using this tutorialif someone is interested. Best lossless codec for exporting video without quality loss on mac and pc for film in premiere pro. Prores is a highperformance editing codec that provides. When i switched to adobe software few years ago i forgot about prores, but then a guy from a shoot sent me a prores file and i remembered it as a delightful format.

The apple prores 422 lt codec provides the following. I hear good things about the codec, but i havent used them yet myself. If you are windows user, please turn to u2usoft total video converter. Dec 27, 2012 apple prores 422 codec is the best codec for final cut pro x editing on mac, once you convert mxf, mts, m2ts, h. Which is the cheapest solution available in this case. Heres another chance to read this article about why its a good idea to use prores, avid dnxhd, and any of the other production quality compression codecs but while its true that more people than ever can afford to make topend video, this new capability poses a few questions for the ideal editing workflow. In this video, author jeff greenberg demonstrates how to create a custom prores master output in adobe premiere pro cc. But in my situation, i have to deal every day with a team that uses different platforms and since prores is a codec conceived specially for apple, people using windows for. Nov 28, 2011 i think its important to understand that all three of these codecs are primarily finishing or intermediate codecs. Back then i was able to export to prores422 with mc5. How to transcode prores to dnxhd easily and quickly i have a 1080p video rendered out with the apple prores codec on a pc. Click here to see a detailed list of the codec features.

I see a lot of posts by us editors about delivering broadcast masters in either prores or if theyre working on or have recently moved to pc, dnxhd. I rendered the animation to the prores 422 hq, prores 422, avid dnxhd 175, avid dnxhd 115, and avid. Some of you already have done this before, so you can guide me. Apple to support dnxhd and dnxhr video codecs after all. Hey everyone, as a filmmaker on final cut pro i always loved apple prores codec for my postproduction works. Roughly 70 percent of the data rate of apple prores 422 thus, smaller file sizes than apple prores 422 higher quality than apple prores 422 proxy apple prores 422 proxy the apple prores 422 proxy codec is intended for use in offline workflows and provides the following. Heres another chance to read this article about why its a good idea to use prores, avid dnxhd, and any of the other production quality compression c page 2 redshark news why you should use avid dnxhd and apple prores page 2. Before i had to format my mac, i still had an older version of final cut pro on it. It is possible to mix and match your codecs throughout your project, but there is a great. Avid delivers video editing workflows with prores raw and. Have not had the time to test the avid codecs under similar conditions within an avid system, but theres no reason to suspect dnxhd wont perform as well in that test as it did in the more informal test. Moreover, you will know how to play prores files on windows and convert prores to h. They can also be downloaded free of charge for systems without avid products installed.

This article is not about apple vs avid or mac vs windows. Nov 30, 2016 hi guys, im quite desperate to find a solution to encode my videos to apple pro res. Why you should use avid dnxhd and apple prores redshark news. Prores raw support comes to avid media composer broadfield news. There are subtle differences between each of the codecs that are recorded and the best codec is the one suited to your particular production. Apple prores is an intermediate codec able to maintain higher quality than enduser codecs and still require much less expensive disk systems compared with uncompressed video and uncompressed videos require much more storage space and higher bandwidth. At work that list is double and we dont have any special package installed.

Initial release of miraizon dnxhd and prores codecs for windows. In addition, apple will provide 64bit decoders for dnxhr and dnxhd codecs within the pro video formats package that is available from apple as a free download for all users. Unfortunately, because the pro apps have the codec built in, apple has removed the codec from their site. It is the successor of the apple intermediate codec and was introduced in 2007 with final cut studio 2. It also supports larger than hd rasters much like pro res does. Nov 06, 2018 this guide will discuss the differences between prores, the proprietary video codec developed by apple inc. Dnxhr is a resolution and framerate independent codec. A look at the old miraizon prores codecs for windows and a few unscientific tests to see if they are really as bad as the reputation they have been left with since their demise. In fact, prores and dnxhd sometimes called intermediate or production codecs sit in a kind of sweet spot between the humongous data rates of uncompressed video, and the egregious processing demands of long gop video. Yes, the dnxhd and prores movies produced by our codecs should play and import fine into any application that supports quicktime. How does cineform compare to apple prores and avid dnxhd.